🎤 WTSFest Philadelphia up next on October 7th
🎟️ Tickets also on sale for Melbourne, London, & Portland
Author: Dii Pooler
Last updated: 25/06/2025
Google just flipped the script on organic search, and some content creators & SEOs are still playing by the old rules.
AI Overviews have quietly become the new prime real estate in search results, appearing above traditional organic listings and stealing clicks from websites that used to dominate page one. What started as an experimental feature is now reshaping how users consume information online.
The numbers tell the story: Semrush data from March 2025 shows AI Overviews now appear in 13.14% of all searches, more than doubling from 6.49% in January. That's not just a trend, it's a fundamental shift in how Google delivers information to users.
But here's what's really interesting: unlike the early days when Google pulled content without attribution, AI Overviews now include proper source citations. This creates an unprecedented opportunity for content creators who understand how to optimize for this new format.
The websites getting featured in these AI-generated summaries aren't just lucky, they're following specific strategies that most SEO professionals haven't figured out yet. They're creating content that AI systems recognize as authoritative, comprehensive, and directly relevant to user queries.
If you're still optimizing content solely for traditional organic rankings, you're missing the bigger picture. The future of SEO isn't about ranking #1 anymore, it's about becoming the source that AI trusts enough to cite and feature.
This completely changes how we approach content strategy, keyword targeting, and what it means to "win" in search results.
At the core of AI Overviews are Large Language Models (LLMs) like Google's Gemini and OpenAI's GPT models. Think of them as super-powered text prediction engines that have read practically the entire internet.
When someone types a question into Google, these LLMs:
To get your content featured in these AI Overviews, you need a basic understanding of how LLMs work. They're not just matching keywords anymore – they're actually trying to understand your content and how helpful it is for real people.
According to Danny Goodwin, Google's AI can now judge content quality much more effectively than old-school algorithms, and it's getting better at spotting truly authoritative content from merely keyword-stuffed content.
Google's AI is looking for content that covers a topic from all angles that matter to real people.
Quick Action Steps:
Google claims they still follow traditional E-E-A-T methods (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness), so showing you actually know what you're talking about and have the ability to connect with people still matters.
You know those invisible bits of code that tell search engines, "hey, this is a product" or "this is a recipe"? That's structured data, and it helps Google's AI figure out what your content is actually about.
Try These:
As noted by Xponent21, "Structured data helps Google's AI understand not just what your content says, but what it means is making it more likely to be included in AI-generated responses."
People are typing whole questions into Google these days, not just keyword phrases. And Google's AI is built to answer these specific questions.
Smart Moves:
According to Frank Olivio, content that addresses specific questions has a 27% better chance of showing up in AI Overviews compared to traditional keyword-focused content.
Google's AI favors content from sources it trusts. Getting quality websites to link to you still matters more than ever now.
What Works:
Google's content guidelines explain that, "Focus on creating satisfying content, demonstrating first-hand expertise and a depth of knowledge." Their AI is designed to reward content that shows deep understanding in a topic rather than surface-level coverage.
Clear, specific, and factually accurate information will help you get featured in those AI Overviews, while vague claims and quick recaps will get you nowhere.
Do This Instead:
Research by Semrush indicates that factually accurate content with clear citations is significantly more likely to be featured in AI Overviews, as Google's systems prioritize reliability and trustworthiness.
It seems like Google changes AI Overviews every other day, and now we're dealing with a spam problem too. You need to watch what's happening and adjust your approach on the fly.
Stay on Top of It:
According to Barry Schwartz, Google is constantly tweaking how AI Overviews work, so what works today might not work tomorrow.
User experience matters more than ever. Fast-loading, mobile-friendly sites that people actually enjoy using have a better chance of getting featured in AI Overviews.
Website Musts:
As Goodwin explains, AI Overviews might cut down on clicks to your site, but pages that offer an excellent user experience still do better in the long run.
While optimizing for AI Overviews presents opportunities, it also comes with challenges:
A growing concern is proper attribution in AI Overviews. Search Engine Land spotted instances where citations were linked to buried information on pages rather than the main content. This means you need to structure your content clearly and make sure your key points aren't hidden away.
Google is fighting an uphill battle against spam in AI Overviews. A recent investigation uncovered people trying to game the system. Focus on creating genuinely helpful content instead of trying to trick the AI – those tricks have a short shelf life anyway.
Let's be honest – when Google answers the question right in the search results, fewer people will click through to your site. You need to offer something more than what the AI summary provides. Give people a reason to want the whole story.
Google's AI Overviews doesn't seem to be going anywhere anytime soon, and they're showing up in more searches every day, and they're getting smarter about which content they feature.
The good news? If you focus on creating genuinely helpful, factually accurate content that answers real human questions, you've got a shot at getting featured. Add some structured data to help Google understand what you're talking about, build your site's authority, keep an eye on trends, and make your site a pleasure to use.
Things are changing fast; you either adapt or get left behind. The good news is that the fundamentals haven't changed that much. Google still wants to show people the best answers to their questions; you just need to make sure your content is the best answer out there.
Will it take work? Of course. But with the strategies we've covered, you've got a decent roadmap to help your content stand out.